A Comprehensive Guide to Winning Tenancy Deposit Disputes

Tenancy deposit disputes arise when landlords and tenants disagree on how much of the deposit should be returned at the end of a tenancy. To protect both parties’ interests and ensure a fair resolution, it is essential to understand the process and the key factors involved.

The Importance of a Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)

Landlords are legally required to protect tenants’ deposits within a government-backed Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS) within 30 days of receiving the funds. These schemes ensure that the deposit is safeguarded and provide a dispute resolution service if disagreements arise.

Choosing the Right TDS

There are three government-backed TDS providers in England and Wales:

  1. Deposit Protection Service (DPS)
  2. MyDeposits
  3. Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)

Each provider has its dispute resolution process, so it’s crucial to understand the specific rules and regulations of the chosen scheme.

Free Landlord Resources

Free Instant Valuation

See how much your property could get in rent.

Fee Saving Calculator

See how much you could save on property fees.

Yield calculator

Calculate your rental yield with our simple tool

Compliance checklist

Make sure your buy-to-let property remains legal.

Compliance Guide

Download your complete landlord compliance guideĀ 

Essential Steps for Landlords

To maximise the chances of winning a tenancy deposit dispute, landlords should follow these critical steps:

1. Provide a Comprehensive Inventory

A detailed inventory is crucial to establish the property’s condition at the start of the tenancy. This document should include:

  • A room-by-room description
  • The condition of fixtures and fittings
  • Photos or videos as supporting evidence

Both parties should sign the inventory to confirm their agreement.

2. Conduct Regular Inspections

Regular property inspections help landlords identify and address any issues promptly. Landlords should provide tenants with written notice before conducting an inspection, and any findings should be documented and shared with the tenant.

3. Maintain Accurate Records

Landlords should keep a thorough record of all communications, receipts, invoices, and any other relevant documents throughout the tenancy. These records can provide vital evidence in case of a dispute.

4. Abide by TDS Regulations

Landlords must adhere to their chosen TDS’s rules and procedures, including submitting evidence within the specified time frame.

The Dispute Resolution Process

In the event of a dispute, both parties should attempt to resolve the issue amicably before involving the TDS. If a resolution cannot be reached, the dispute resolution process will typically involve the following stages:

  1. Submission of Evidence: Both parties submit their evidence to the TDS.
  2. Review and Decision: An impartial adjudicator reviews the evidence and makes a decision.
  3. Appeal Process: If either party disagrees with the decision, they may have the option to appeal, depending on the TDS’s specific rules.


Winning a tenancy deposit dispute hinges on thorough preparation, clear communication, and adherence to the regulations set by the chosen Tenancy Deposit Scheme. By following the essential steps outlined in this guide, both landlords and tenants can increase their chances of achieving a fair outcome in any deposit dispute.

Top Tips for Avoiding Tenancy Deposit Disputes

To minimise the risk of deposit disputes, landlords and tenants should consider implementing the following best practices:

  1. Provide Clear Tenancy Agreements: Ensure the tenancy agreement clearly outlines the terms and conditions, including the tenant’s responsibilities and any deductions that may be made from the deposit.
  2. Offer a Fair Wear and Tear Policy: Landlords should accept that some wear and tear is inevitable and establish a reasonable policy for dealing with minor damages.
  3. Establish Open Communication Channels: Encourage tenants to raise concerns or report issues promptly, fostering a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

Meet Sam your local Expert

Sam has a wealth of experience across the private landlord and Build to Rent sectors. He has advised a wide range of clients across the whole of London on how to find great tenants, improve their assets and effectively market their properties for the best returns.

Our Trusted Partners

As Featured on